Director: Claude Jutra
Studio: National Film Board of Canada/The Criterion Collection 438 [Release date: July 8, 08]
Video: 1.66:1 enhanced for 16:9, color
Audio: French or dubbed English, DD mono (center chan. or L & R channels)
Subtitles: English
Extras: Theatrical trailer, “On Screen! “Mon oncle Antoine” (2007 documentary), “Claude Jutra: An Unfinished Story (2002 documentary), “A Chairy Tale” (1957 pixelated short codirected by Jutra and Norman McLaren, Illustrated booklet with new essay by film scholar André Loiselle
Length: 104 minutes
Rating: *****
Generally regarded as the best Canadian feature film ever made, Mon Oncle Antoine was the masterpiece by influential director Jutra, who later committed suicide due to the ravages of early-onset Alzeimers. Jutra worked with Francois Truffaut and is often credited as Canada’s Jean Renoir. The film is a subtle and realistic portrayal of the coming of age of 15-year-old Benoit, all on a Christmas Eve. It is full of the ironic humanism and mischievous sentimentalism that is Jutra’s style.
The setting is the early 1940s in a rural Quebec asbestos-mining town which not only stands in for itself but many of its inhabitants play the miners and their families in the film. The mine is owned by an English company and during the film there is one death of a middle-aged miner which presages the coming Asbestos Strike of the late 1940s, as well as Benoit and a pal throwing snowballs at the mine’s English owner when he rides thru the town dispensing Christmas trinkets.
The many documentaries on which Jutra worked show their influence in Mon Oncle Antoine, giving it an ultra-realistic air. The lovely cinematography is beautifully restored by Criterion, in spite of the challenges of some of the realistic lighting, as explained by cinematographer Michel Brault in the extras included on the second DVD of the packed package. By the way, it’s great to have a good print of the delightful “dance” film to music by Ravi Shankar – A Chairy Tale – one of the National Film Board’s prize-winning shorts that everyone should see. While I still disagree with Criterion’s decision to encode all their soundtracks with Dolby Digital instead of mono or stereo PCM, I do appreciate their offering the mono signals on channels 1 & 2 as an alternative to using the center channel – which usually means a smaller, compromised speaker.
– John Sunier